Vegan Meat Alternatives

By Anne Custer

Meat substitutes come in handy for easy meals that require minimal preparation. Use deli slices to make a vegan club, put "meatballs" into your spaghetti, add "chick'n" to your stir-fry, or wake up to a breakfast of vegan sausage and bacon. There are substitutes for deli slices, meatballs and ground meat, poultry, bacon, and sausage. The trouble is choosing which is best for you with all the options available. This guide is here to help you to nutritionally compare some products on the market to make the best choice for your dietary needs.

Deli Slices

Lightlife, Yves, Tofurky, and Field Roast have provided vegans and meat eaters alike with the means to make sandwiches with "meat." The analogs are fairly low in calories, ranging from 50-110 per serving, and offer classic flavors like turkey, ham, bologna, pepperoni, and salami. Although they are not organic, Lightlife, Tofurky, and Field Roast are all made with non-GMO soy. The average serving size is 4 slices (about 2 ounces), not including the outlier of 13 slices (1 ounce) for Tofurky's Pepperoni. They are all low in carbohydrates with the highest level in Tofurky's Italian Deli Slices at 7 grams per 5 slices and the lowest level in Yves Bologna at 2 grams per 4 slices. The substitutes have an average of 2 grams of fat per serving and a negligible amount of saturated fat. The average protein per serving is 13 grams, which is similar to the protein in a serving of oven-roasted turkey lunch meat, which has 11 grams of protein. If you are avoiding gluten, meatless deli slices are not for you. These products are all derived from wheat, but there are some gluten-free options in other substitutes highlighted in this guide.

Meatballs and Ground Meat

Here at The Vegetarian Resource Group, we had the pleasure of tasting Beyond Meat's Italian and Swedish Meatballs. Our senior editor, Samantha Gendler, served them over spaghetti squash with tomato sauce to her non-vegan friends who couldn't tell the difference. These meatballs are made with pea protein so they can be used by those with gluten or soy allergies. The average serving size for meatless meatballs is four. They range from 90-200 calories per serving and average 13 grams of protein. Amy's is the only organic offering and Nate's are made with non-GMO soy. The average fat content is 7 grams and each has a negligible amount of saturated fat.

Meat crumbles, or ground "meat", come in different forms. Many are made to be added to dishes like chili, spaghetti, or tacos, but some can be molded into burgers or meatballs. Neat and Beyond Meat both offer gluten-free and soy-free products that can be shaped into different forms. Neat's products are made with pecans, so those with nut allergies should be mindful. Match's crumbles are gluten-free as well and Upton's are made with non-GMO soy. Per 1.5-ounce serving, Match has the fewest calories at 46 calories and Neat's Mexican Mix has the most calories at 235 calories.

Poultry Substitutes

This was by far the largest category of meat substitutes. Brands from MorningStar to Gardein to Simply Balanced offer vegan chicken to consumers. With flavors such as Teriyaki, Kung Pao, Barbeque, and Thai Basil, it's almost impossible not to find a poultry analog that fits your taste. These also come in different shapes such as tenders, wings, nuggets, patties, strips, and even half of a vegan chicken. Nutritional value varies greatly due to the wide range of products and options. Tofurky, Gardein, Beyond Meat, Lightlife, and Vegetarian Plus are all made with non-GMO soy. Tofurky's Lightly Seasoned Slow Roasted Chick'n has the highest fat content at 22 grams per 3.2-ounce serving compared to Lightlife Smart Chick'n Strips, which have 0 grams of fat per 3-ounce serving. The substitutes are all low in saturated fat. Please note that other than Smart Chick'n Strips, other Lightlife's Chick'n products are not vegan because they contain egg.

Bacon Slices and Sausage

As a vegan, one of the questions I'm asked most frequently is whether or not I miss bacon. I don't miss anything, except maybe the convenience, but that seems to be changing, especially with the addition of these meat substitutes. Yves even offers a Canadian Bacon substitute. These bacon analogs are all derived from wheat and soy sources. Lightlife, Tofurky, and Upton's are all made with non-GMO soy. The aforementioned brands, with the addition of Yves, all have a small amount of fat averaging 1 gram per 3-slice serving and a negligible amount of saturated fat. Three slices of veggie bacon have 60-80 calories and average around 12 grams of protein. Compare that to the nutritional value of three slices of pork bacon at 160 calories, 12 grams of fat, 11 grams of protein, and 4 grams of saturated fat and you have yourself a much healthier replacement.

As for sausage, SoL Cuisine is the only gluten-free option and is made with non-GMO soy. Other brands made with non-GMO soy are Tofurky, Lightlife, Field Roast, and Gardein. The analogs highest in calories are Tofurky Italian and Tofurky Andouille, both at 270 calories per 3.5-ounce serving. Lightlife Gimme Lean, SoL Cuisine Patties, and 365 Everyday Patties all contain 60 calories per 2-ounce, 1.3-ounce, and 1.3-ounce serving, respectively. Tofurky Beer Brats and Italian have the highest fat content at 13 grams per 3.5-ounce serving and Lightlife Gimme Lean Sausage has the lowest at 0 grams per 2 oz serving. The average saturated fat content was negligible. Please note that Lightlife's Smart Sausages are not vegan because they contain egg.

Deli SlicesServing SizeCalories Per ServingProtein Per Serving (g)Fat Per Serving (g)Carbohydrates Per Serving (g)Saturated Fat Per Serving (g)Iron Per Serving (mg)
Field Roast Lentil Sage Deli Slices 3 slices, 52 grams 100 14 2.5 6 0 1.1
Field Roast Smoked Tomato Deli Slices 3 slices, 52 grams 100 14 2.5 6 0 1.4
Field Roast Wild Mushroom Deli Slices 3 slices, 52 grams 100 12 3 6 0 1.1
Lightlife Smart Deli Bologna Slices 4 slices, 52 grams 70 13 1 3 0 1.4
Lightlife Smart Deli Ham Slices 4 slices, 52 grams 70 12 1 4 0 1.1
Lightlife Smart Deli Pepperoni Slices 13 slices, 30 grams 50 8 0.5 3 0 0.7
Lightlife Smart Deli Turkey Slices 4 slices, 52 grams 100 14 3.5 4 0.5 1.4
Tofurky Bologna Style Deli Slices 3 slices, 52 grams 100 14 3 5 0 1.1
Tofurky Hickory Smoked Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 100 13 3 6 0 1.1
Tofurky Italian Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 110 11 4 7 1 1.1
Tofurky Oven Roasted Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 100 13 3 6 0 1.1
Tofurky Peppered Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 100 13 3 6 0 1.1
Tofurky Pepperoni Deli Slices 8 slices, 28 grams 60 7 0.5 6 0 1.1
Tofurky Roast Beef Style Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 100 13 3 5 0 1.1
Tofurky Smoked Ham Style Deli Slices 5 slices, 52 grams 100 14 3 5 0 4.5
Yves Meatless Deli Bologna Deli Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 80 14 2.5 2 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Deli Salami Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 80 15 0 4 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Deli Turkey Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 100 16 1.5 5 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Ham Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 100 15 2 5 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Pepperoni 6 slices, 48 grams 80 14 1 4 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Roast without the Beef Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 110 15 2.5 4 0 3.6
Yves Meatless Smoked Chicken Slices 4 slices, 62 grams 100 16 1.5 5 0 3.6
MeatballsServing SizeCalories Per ServingProtein Per Serving (g)FatPerServing(g)Carbohydrates Per Serving (g)Saturated Fat Per Serving (g)Iron Per Serving mg
364 Everyday Value Original Meatless Meatballs 4 balls, 60 grams 110 12 4 9 0 1.1
Amy's Original Meatless Meatballs 8 balls 190 14 5 24 0.5 2.7
Beyond Meat Italian Meatballs 4 balls, 85 grams 200 18 12 6 2 0.7
Beyond Meat Swedish Meatballs 4 balls, 85 grams 200 18 12 6 2 0.7
Gardein Classic Meatless Meatballs 3 balls, 90 grams 150 17 6 10 0 2.7
Nate's Original Meatless Meatballs 3 balls, 43 grams 90 7 4.5 5 0 1.1
Nate's Savory Mushroom Meatless Meatballs 3 balls, 43 grams 100 8 4.5 6 0 1.8
Nate's Zesty Italian Meatless Meatballs 3 balls, 43 grams 110 10 4.5 9 0 1.4
Ground BeefServing SizeCalories Per ServingProtein Per Serving (g)FatPerServing (g)Carbohydrates Per Serving (g)Saturated Fat Per Serving (g)Iron Per Serving (mg)
Beyond Meat Beefy Crumble 1/2 cup, 55 grams 100 13 4.5 3 0 0.4
Beyond Meat Feisty Crumble 1/2 cup, 55 grams 120 13 5 3 0 0.4
Boca Ground Veggie Crumbles 57 grams 60 13 0.5 6 0 1.8
Match Ground Beef 3.5 ounces, 100 grams 100 18 1.5 7 0 n/a
Neat Breakfast Mix 40 grams 200 5 14 6 1 3.6
Neat Italian Mix 40 grams 190 4 15 12 1.5 1.4
Neat Mexican Mix 40 grams 210 5 15 16 1.5 1.4
Neat Original Mix 40 grams 190 4 15 11 1.5 1.4
Upton's Ground Seitan 2 ounces, 57 grams 100 15 1.5 7 0 1.4

Comparing Sodium Levels

Sodium is typically the main concern in faux meats. While our cells need sodium to function properly, too much sodium can lead to high blood pressure and cardiovascular disease, among other problems. To help identify lower-sodium products, I've ranked products lowest to highest in sodium content by product.

Deli Slices (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. Field Roast Wild Mushroom Deli Slices 160 mg; Yves Meatless Deli Turkey Slices 160 mg
  2. Yves Meatless Roast without the Beef Slices 170 mg
  3. Tofurky Smoked Ham, Oven Roasted, Peppered, Smoked, or Italian Deli Slices 175 mg
  4. Lightlife Smart Deli Turkey Slices 180 mg; Tofurky Pepperoni Slices 180 mg
  5. Tofurky Bologna Style Deli Slices 185 mg
  6. Lightlife Smart Deli Ham Slices 190 mg
  7. Yves Meatless Deli Bologna Slices 215 mg
  8. Field Roast Lentil Sage Deli Slices 220 mg
  9. Tofurky Roast Beef Style Deli Slices 225 mg
  10. Yves Meatless Ham, Salami or Smoked Chicken Deli Slices 230 mg
  11. Yves Meatless Pepperoni 245 mg
  12. Lightlife Smart Deli Pepperoni Slices 250 mg
  13. Field Roast Smoked Tomato Deli Slices 260 mg
  14. Lightlife Smart Deli Bologna Slices 300 mg

Meatballs (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. Beyond Beef Italian or Swedish Meatballs 125 mg
  2. Gardein Meatless Meatballs 130 mg
  3. Nate's Savory Mushroom Meatless Meatballs 165 mg
  4. 365 Everyday Value Meatless Meatballs 185 mg; Nate's Original Meatless Meatballs 185 mg
  5. Amy's Meatless Veggie Meatballs 220 mg
  6. Nate's Zesty Italian Meatless Meatballs 235 mg

Ground Meat (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. Match Ground Beef 90 mg
  2. Upton's Ground Seitan 140 mg; Boca Veggie Crumbles 140 mg
  3. Neat Breakfast Mix 160 mg
  4. Beyond Beef Crumbles 190 mg
  5. Neat Italian Mix 250 mg
  6. Neat Original Mix 265 mg
  7. Neat Mexican Mix 375 mg

Poultry (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. Gardein Zesty Marinara Crispy Chick'n Filets 85 mg
  2. Simply Balanced Smoky Chipotle Meatless Chicken 95 mg
  3. Field Roast Sunflower Country-Style Breaded Cutlets 100 mg
  4. Gardein Mandarin Orange Crispy Chick'n, Teriyaki Chick'n Strips, Crispy Chick'n Patty, Crispy Chick'n Sliders 105 mg; Vegetarian Plus Vegan Half Chicken 105 mg
  5. Field Roast Hazelnut Herb or Coconut Breaded Cutlets 115 mg
  6. Gardein Chipotle Lime Crispy Fingers and Vegetarian Plus Tikki Masala Vegan Chicken 120 mg; Beyond Meat Grilled or Lightly Seasoned Strips 120 mg
  7. Beyond Meat Southwest Style Strips 125 mg; Lightlife Smart Chick'n Strips 125 mg
  8. Simply Balanced Korean Barbeque and Teriyaki Meatless Chicken 130 mg
  9. Upton's Naturals Chick Seitan 140 mg; Gardein Seven Grain Crispy Tenders or Sweet and Tangy BBQ Wings 140 mg
  10. Tofurky BBQ Slow Roasted Chick'n 145 mg; Gardein Lightly Seasoned Chick'n Scaloppini 145 mg; WestSoy Chicken Style Seitan 145 mg
  11. Tofurky Tandoori Slow Roasted Chick'n 150 mg; Vegetarian Plus Chicken Strips 150 mg
  12. Vegetarian Plus Korean Sesame Vegan Chicken 155 mg; Tofurky Lightly Seasoned Slow Roasted Chick'n 155 mg
  13. MorningStar Griller Chick'n Veggie Patty 160 mg; Beyond Meat Homestyle or Southwest Style Tenders 160 mg
  14. Vegetarian Plus Orange Vegan Chicken 165 mg
  15. Yves Meatless Chicken Burger 170 mg; Tofurky Thai Basil Slow Roasted Chick'n 170 mg; Beyond Meat Feisty Buffalo or Sesame Ginger Poppers 170 mg; Vegetarian Plus Chicken Drumsticks 170 mg; Boca Original Chick'n Veggie Nuggets 170 mg
  16. Vegetarian Plus Non Breaded Chicken Nuggets 175 mg
  17. Vegetarian Plus Teriyaki Vegan Chicken 180 mg
  18. Vegetarian Plus Ginger Vegan Chicken 185 mg; Tofurky Sesame Garlic Slow Roasted Chick'n 185 mg
  19. Vegetarian Plus Kung Pao Vegan Chicken 195 mg
  20. Vegetarian Plus Black Pepper Chicken Tenders or Chicken Steaks 210 mg
  21. Boca Spicy Chick'n Veggie Patties 230 mg

Bacon Slices (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. Tofurky Smoked Maple Bacon Marinated Tempeh 105 mg
  2. Upton's Naturals Bacon Seitan 130 mg
  3. Yves Meatless Canadian Bacon 210 mg
  4. Lightlife Smart Bacon 450 mg

Sausage (sodium in 1 ounce)

  1. 365 Everyday Value Meatless Breakfast Patties 105 mg
  2. Gardein Sausage Breakfast Patties 145 mg
  3. Tofurky Spinach Pesto Artisan Sausage 160 mg
  4. Tofurky Andouille Artisan Sausage 165 mg; Lightlife Gimme Lean Meatless Sausage 165 mg
  5. Field Roast Mexican Chipotle Grain Meat Sausage 170 mg
  6. Tofurky Chick'n and Apple Artisan Sausage 175 mg
  7. Tofurky Beer Brats Gourmet Sausage or Italian Gourmet Sausage 185 mg; Field Roast Italian Grain Meat Sausage 185 mg
  8. Yves Sausage Breakfast Patties 190 mg
  9. Field Roast Smoked Apple Sage Grain Meat Sausage 195 mg
  10. Tofurky Kielbasa Gourmet Sausage 200 mg
  11. SoL Cuisine Sausage Breakfast Patties 205 mg
  12. Tofurky Sausage Breakfast Links 215 mg
  13. Field Roast Apple Maple Breakfast Sausage 220 mg

This product guide was developed by Anne Custer while interning with The Vegetarian Resource Group. Special thanks to VRG's Nutrition Advisor Reed Mangels, PhD, RD for working with her on this piece.

For more comparative charts on meat alternatives, see our website at http://www.vrg.org/journal/vj2016issue1/AdditionalMeatAlternativesCharts.pdf.