Vegetarian Journal July/Aug 1998
Vegetarian Action
Sci-Veg--An Internet Discussion of Science and Vegetarianism
By Carl V. Phillips
"But then [I] saw it on the Internet, and I knew it must be true."
This quotation, which I have posted on my door (taken out of context from
a New York Times article), should provoke a chuckle from anyone familiar
with life on the net. The Internet is a storehouse of virtually unlimited
information and a meeting-place for countless people. Sometimes this is
not an altogether good thing. Unfortunately, sorting out good information
from misinformation or finding good discussions on the Internet can be
a challenge.
Vegetarians who are looking for information and social interaction have
hundreds of options on the Internet. Some of them, like VRG's
Web site (www.vrg.org), are good sources of carefully compiled information,
but most are less reliable. Furthermore, Web sites, good or bad, are basically
on-line magazines or pamphlets, and so do not tap into the interactive
potential of the Internet. Interactive resources, like bulletin boards
and e-mail lists, often present inaccurate information about technical
subjects because few scientific experts contribute to the discussion. The
result is the persistence of myths in the vegetarian community about everything
from calcium needs to food ingredients, and from resource usage to economics.
In early 1996, it was clear that there was a need for an Internet group
that rose to the challenge of promoting accurate information and providing
a place for lively discussion among those interested in vegetarianism.
I founded Sci-Veg along with a half dozen other researchers and activists,
including vegetarian author and dietitian Virginia (Ginny) Messina, M.P.H.,
R.D. Sci-Veg is the only Internet resource devoted to the discussion of
vegetarian issues from a scientific perspective.
We created it for two purposes. First, it concentrates many researchers,
practitioners, and long-time vegetarians in one place so list members can
find good information. Naturally, we have not been able to answer every
question from the thousands of posts Sci-Veg has had since its creation.
But readers could be assured that incorrect or unsupportable claims, the
curse of most Internet discussions, would rarely slip by without response
from knowledgeable list members. In addition, Sci-Veg provides a forum
for experts in various fields to discuss their work, formulate new ideas,
and develop useful collaborations. Advancing the state of knowledge in
any field requires people to combine their ideas and knowledge, and the
vegetarian community has had limited resources for such exchanges.
Some topics recently discussed on Sci-Veg include:
-
Does drinking milk raise risk for osteoporosis?
-
Are vegetarians more likely than other people to believe health misinformation?
-
Is there any truth to the idea that blood type affects a person's optimal
diet?
It is hard to gauge the impact of a project like Sci-Veg, but it is my
impression that it has had a substantial impact. I am aware of several
productive collaborations that have formed and issues discussed among Sci-Veg
s writers and researchers. For many non-expert readers, we have, I believe,
provided a better understanding of important issues relating to nutrition,
food science, economics, public health, psychology, environmental science,
anthropology, sociology, and philosophy. A perusal of other Internet discussions
turns up frequent references to Sci-Veg, either cited as a source or recommended
as a better place to ask a technical question. Several persistent myths
that have been challenged on Sci-Veg seem to be fading (although, naturally,
the exact role of Sci-Veg discussions cannot be determined). For example,
Sci-Veg led the challenge against the mistaken belief that producing a
pound of beef uses 2,500 gallons of water, and few people seem to still
believe that myth.1
Other recent topics include questions about nutrition and health, the
accuracy of various popular books on vegetarianism, and the environmental
and economic impacts of your diet. If you are interested in these topics,
or would like to bring up one of your own, you are invited to join. Experts
in any technical or scientific field (even if it is not directly related
to vegetarianism) are especially encouraged to join and contribute their
wisdom.
To join Sci-Veg, just send the e-mail message
subscribe sci-veg
in the body of the message to waste@waste.org
or point your Web browser to http://www.waste.org/sci-veg
to learn more about the list.
1A better estimate, in the range of 400-500 gallons/pound,
is given by J.L. Beckett and J.W. Oltjen (J Animal Science, 1993. 71; 818-826).
See http://www.waste.org/sci-veg/sci-veg.9609/4.html
for further discussion.
Excerpts from the Jul/Aug Issue:
The Vegetarian Journal published here is not the complete issue,
but these are excerpts from the published magazine. Anyone wanting to see
everything should subscribe to the magazine.
This article was converted to HTML by Jeanie
Freeman
 |
© 1996-2013
The Vegetarian Resource Group
PO Box 1463, Baltimore, MD 21203
(410) 366-8343 Email: vrg@vrg.org
|
|
Last Updated
July 6, 1998
|
Graphic
design by |
|
The contents of this web site, as with
all The Vegetarian Resource Group publications, is not
intended to provide personal medical advice. Medical
advice should be obtained from a qualified health
professional.
Any pages on this site may be
reproduced for non-commercial use if left intact
and with credit given to The Vegetarian Resource Group.
Web site questions or comments? Please email
brad@vrg.org.
|